Multiple air tanks

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Seajay
    replied
    Originally posted by Trbo323
    You could run a gas through T stock. May be lighter than the 13 even.

    Or is there a way to input air in front of the trigger frame? I swear I saw that somewhere. If so just input the 77 there instead

    Sent from my Moto Z (2) using Tapatalk
    On a phenom? That sounds wild and crazy and I have no idea how that might be done, but sounds interesting. The gas line is on the back of the Flex Valve, on the bottom just in front of the rear cap.

    The A5 has the air in front of the frame.

    Leave a comment:


  • Trbo323
    replied
    You could run a gas through T stock. May be lighter than the 13 even.

    Or is there a way to input air in front of the trigger frame? I swear I saw that somewhere. If so just input the 77 there instead

    Sent from my Moto Z (2) using Tapatalk

    Leave a comment:


  • Seajay
    commented on 's reply
    Thanks for testing. I'll only be using 1 remote, with the 13ci direct fed to the ASA, so I think some of the volume restriction should be mitigated. The 13ci should just be acting as a big ass expansion chamber.

  • Seajay
    replied
    Cool, thanks for testing.

    The plan again, is to use the 13ci and have the 77ci in reserve. The mobility offered by the 13ci as a Stock has a lot of advantages I don't want to give up, mostly freedom of movement.

    I am not trying to fill the 13ci from the 77ci, just to use the 77ci through the 13ci if/when I need too.
    I get about 125 shot off a 13ci, which is 6 magazines at 114 shots, so I should theoretically be ok, unless the battle gets really long, which for Fulda it very well could.

    I did a little testing as well and I think it will actually work just fine with the 13ci. The tank volume is quite small and seems to recharge quickly. I will mostly be shooting semi so I don't expect to need the air volume for high bps. I also went ahead and adjusted the output pressure on the tank to ~900 psi.

    There are of course much simpler, easier methods to this madness. I could just run remote. I could also buy more 13ci tanks. But that's too easy :P I also don't have another 13ci, but I do have a remote and this fancy 77ci, which is very light. Not to mention these extra parts not being used...

    Screenshot_20211025-124005_Gallery.jpg

    Leave a comment:


  • Trbo323
    replied
    It only half worked. There's a flow rate issue. At low bps it works fine but start cranking up the rounds and it falls on its face

    My tank on the scuba is outputting 850 so yeah, shp output needed if you want a chance at making this work for anything over 5bps I'd say

    Sent from my Moto Z (2) using Tapatalk

    Leave a comment:


  • Trbo323
    replied


    Originally posted by Chuck E Ducky
    It’s only going to fill the wip and 2nd tank with regulated pressure off the 77ci. It won’t leak as long as it’s attached to the marker and the Air wip is functioning properly. It’s acting as a pass threw at that point. You would fill the 77 just like you would with any remote line setup. Basically charge the 77 let up, it will balance the pressure in the 13 to whatever the 77 reg is set to.
    If you are talking not removing the guts of the 13 then yes, this works but then there's also no real reason to have the 13 on the marker either, just remote line straight into the ASA and go with an adjustable stock

    If he wants to fill both tanks this also works (get an asa with a slide check to make life easy) my only question is if there will be any flow rate issues (testing in a few, just got home)

    If you want him to remove the guts of either regulator and either one is any kind of a halfway modern design, it will cause a fairly substantial leak

    Sent from my Moto Z (2) using Tapatalk

    Leave a comment:


  • Chuck E Ducky
    replied
    It’s only going to fill the wip and 2nd tank with regulated pressure off the 77ci. It won’t leak as long as it’s attached to the marker and the Air wip is functioning properly. It’s acting as a pass threw at that point. You would fill the 77 just like you would with any remote line setup. Basically charge the 77 let up, it will balance the pressure in the 13 to whatever the 77 reg is set to.

    Leave a comment:


  • Trbo323
    replied


    Originally posted by Chuck E Ducky
    Why couldn’t you just remove the 13ci reg guts hook a remote line to it permanently and fill them both at the same time. It would give you the same results and all your parts attached would be rated to your required pressure. The 13 would just act at a pass threw but hold more air volume. Like a big expansion chamber.

    You could probably remove the pin shims and piston. It would then just act as a pass threw and as long as your remote line was attached and on would fill the 13ci at the same time. Just don’t fill it higher then the 13ci is rated for (3k)
    Few problems with that

    1) if you remove the guts it will leak, look at the animation I have above, see that hole next to the piston? It's there because the volume of that chamber changes as the piston moves, remove the piston and you create a leak there. Most regs have that hole because without it the regulator can be sluggish/inconsistent

    2) even if that's not the case and it doesn't have that hole, the remote lines are not rated for 3k, you would have to get a fill whip

    3) and even if you did get a fill whip, you wouldn't be filling the 77 unless the line is hooked into the fill nipple. You can't back fill through a regulator because it's the output side that closes the regulator. If you increase the pressure on the output side it will just hold the regulator closed and your are also risking damaging the seat

    The way he has it set up should work, if I get some time tomorrow I'll test it because I have everything already

    Also, if the 13ci is just going to act as an x chamber, you might as well ditch it and just run the 77 in remote setup. There's no advantage to having the 13 there with only enough air to fire a few shots

    One question for the op though, are you even going to be able to carry enough paint to make 2 tanks worth it? The phenom isn't the most efficient design but you will still be closing in on a full case of paint to empty both tanks

    Sent from my Moto Z (2) using Tapatalk

    Leave a comment:


  • Chuck E Ducky
    replied
    Why couldn’t you just remove the 13ci reg guts hook a remote line to it permanently and fill them both at the same time. It would give you the same results and all your parts attached would be rated to your required pressure. The 13 would just act at a pass threw but hold more air volume. Like a big expansion chamber.

    You could probably remove the pin shims and piston. It would then just act as a pass threw and as long as your remote line was attached and on would fill the 13ci at the same time. Just don’t fill it higher then the 13ci is rated for (3k)

    Leave a comment:


  • Trbo323
    replied
    Gaah! I hate comments, I use a app to view the forum and it doesn't display comments. It shows me there are 18 replies to a thread but I can only see the 14 of them that are posts. I didn't even realize you guys replied until this morning.



    Sent from my Moto Z (2) using Tapatalk

    Leave a comment:


  • Seajay
    commented on 's reply
    Sweet! Well I won't be blasting to a rate that would require a high recharge rate, so as long as semi works fine that's all I care about

  • MrBarraclough
    commented on 's reply
    Thanks for the correction.

  • Trbo323
    replied


    Originally posted by MrBarraclough
    This seems to be a question of what the regulator on the 13ci bottle will do with 550psi input pressure. That reg is sprung to step pressures of up to 3000psi down to ~800psi. But there's some minimum threshold pressure it needs to see on the tank side before anything passes through; it won't necessarily pass everything from 0 up to 800. Tank regs don't usually let you shoot all the way down to ambient atmospheric pressure: there will come a point before that at which the tank pressure cannot overcome the springs in the reg.
    Unless I'm wildly miss-interpreting what you mean here, this is wrong. Reg springs are there to open up the regulator not close it. Regulators work by using the output pressure to close the regulator, when that pressure dips (because you shot the marker) the spring then assists in opening up the reg to allow more pressure through. Which then brings the pressure back up and closes the regulator off again.

    You can take a tank all the way down to atmospheric pressure, can you shoot it that low? No, the marker won't cycle but that doesn't mean the tank won't output air, pull it off and push the pin valve if you don't believe me.

    See the animation below, this is the basic design of the vast vast majority of tank regs out there.

    This should work, the only problem I think you might run into is a flow rate issue because flowing air through 3 regs and a remote line is a lot of turns and bends and seals. This weekend if I get a minute I can probably test this for you. I have 2 remote lines and 3 tanks, if one of my tanks is empty I can chain the whole thing together and put a marker on the other end. Heck, I have a crossover, that's the same valve train as the phenom

    Sent from my Moto Z (2) using Tapatalk


    Last edited by Trbo323; 10-21-2021, 08:58 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Seajay
    replied
    I wish I had full air to test this at home with, which is why I'm being so chatty

    But, I did put a little air into my 77ci using my 3k hand pump. I just wanted to see if it would work conceptually at all. The answer is yes, but I'm not sure to the effectiveness.
    I think you are right that the 800psi output reg could be an issue with a 550psi fill from the 77ci.

    The phenom was able to dry fire reliably from some amount of air from the 77ci to the 0 13ci. It did take a second for the 13ci to equalize with the 77ci, and I could hear it. Once pressurized the Phenom cycled fine. I don't know what the output PSI is, I can test that later, but it must be at least 550spi for the initial attempts (I'm assuming).

    The 13ci reg can shoot to empty, but I don't know if that fall off means less than 800 psi output.

    Super interesting observations, I hope to have some feedback soon.

    Leave a comment:


  • MrBarraclough
    replied
    This seems to be a question of what the regulator on the 13ci bottle will do with 550psi input pressure. That reg is sprung to step pressures of up to 3000psi down to ~800psi. But there's some minimum threshold pressure it needs to see on the tank side before anything passes through; it won't necessarily pass everything from 0 up to 800. Tank regs don't usually let you shoot all the way down to ambient atmospheric pressure: there will come a point before that at which the tank pressure cannot overcome the springs in the reg. The output range has both an upper and a lower bound. I have no idea how wide the range might be and how much it may vary from one brand of regulator to another. How far down have you been able to shoot the 13ci tank previously? (not that tank gauges are especially precise, but it should give a rough idea)

    [Edit: Ignore the above. Trbo323 is correct. For some silly reason I was thinking of regs having springs in both directions but with unbalanced tension. I wish the text editor had a strikeout option.]

    djeclypse makes a very good point: Will the reg on the 13ci even output air at all while it is receiving pressure via its fill nipple? I imagine that is a question of internal geometry, specifically, whether the piston from the fill nipple cuts off (or severely reduces) flow to the regulator when it is being pushed in by input pressure. Using a shared passage should not by itself be a problem, so long as the fill nipple piston isn't sitting someplace through which air needs to flow.
    Last edited by MrBarraclough; 10-21-2021, 09:15 AM.

    Leave a comment:

Working...