If you had to choose one?

[Tinybear]

Obviously the Mag.

[FredMnkyDad10]

Mag for sure, but yeah not easy choice.

[coyote]

My primary shooter is a sniper, so that.

I'm to ham handed for a pump mag. I have owned one, but that's not me.

[anson]

Hey Meleager7 just did a quick tally of votes and it's 8 likes for sniper vs 8 likes for pump mag.

Seems to be closer than you thought.

Most were like this

And a few of you be like this

[Meleager7]

....damn mag guys coming out of the woodwork, and skewing the results!

[Alexndl]

I am voting for the sniper
was not able to get use to the feel of my pump mag

[MrBarraclough]

Keep the mag, but lose the pump arm and restore it to its proper configuration. There's something unholy about pump converted mags.

[BLachance75]

Pump Mag because it is easier to swap back and forth between semi and pump.

[Dusty Bottoms]

Mag of course, but Sniper builds are cool too.

[Tinybear]

I think this all boils down to form vs function lol.

As a mechanic I can compare things like

Mags are like a modern internal combustion engine. Small packages that can offer great performance reliability and Lower maintenance. They’re very intricately engineered with very tight tolerances but it’s all built in so well hidden from plain sight and most will never have them opened up. Just change the oil now and then and keep plugging Away.

Cockers are like steam engines aka external combustion engines. They look amazingly cool and are intricate pieces of engineering. They have lots of visible moving parts and when done just right function very well but do require more maintenance and know how.

So I leave it at this which engine are you going to bet on getting you home.

MAGS FOR THE WIN lol

[cougar20th]

For me it would be the mag without hesitation.

[Funsi00]

Pump mag first choice. Although, I won’t turn down that sniper either.

[lew]

Not a pump fan, but Sniper all the way. The milling on that looks great, and I like right feeds.

[Riot]

My stock class mag is the best pump I’ve shot to date. (Cerberus kit)

I’m taking the mag!

[JOESPUD27]

P-Mag